Year: 2010

POSEN CONSTRUCTION INC
Year: 2010
District: 2
Project Number: 098019
PID Number: 25555
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim: 02-098019-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: WOO - IR/LUC-75-32.68/0.00
Description: Extra Hydro-demolition work due to thicker overlay on deck than shown on plans
Issues: Differing site conditions, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Entitlement agreed/damages in dispute
Decision/Recommendation: 02-098019-01

SPECIALIZED CONSTRUCTION INC
Year: 2010
District: 3
Project Number: 080477
PID Number: 80050
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim: 03-080477-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CRA - VA-CHIP-FY2009
Description: Chip Seal Warranty
Issues: Warranty, Acceptance (express/implied)
Decision/Recommendation: 03-080477-01

NATIONAL ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING COMPANY
Year: 2010
District: 6
Project Number: 040163
PID Number: 77003
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim: 06-040163-07
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: FRA - SR 161/IR 270-25.900/40.260-Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: Failure of 1500 mm pipe
Issues: Workmanlike construction, Defective specification, Delay - owner caused, Pipe removal
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040163-07

NATIONAL ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING COMPANY
Year: 2010
District: 6
Project Number: 040163
PID Number: 77003
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim: 06-040163-09
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: FRA - SR 161/IR 270-25.900/40.260-Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: Failing Epoxy Urethane Sealer
Issues: Defective specification, Workmanlike construction, Precaution against damage
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040163-09

A P O'HORO COMPANY
Year: 2010
District: 11
Project Number: 080618
PID Number: 80116
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim: 11-080618-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: COL - SR-164-21.81
Description: Method of Measurement of Composite Fiber Wrap System
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Duty to examine Bid Documents, Past practice
Decision/Recommendation: 11-080618-01

SHELLY & SANDS INC
Year: 2010
District: 11
Project Number: 091002
PID Number: 84342
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim: 11-091002-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: HAS - SR-9-9.38
Description: Disposition of Improperly Placed RPMs
Issues: Workmanlike construction, Acceptance (express/implied), Past practice
Decision/Recommendation: 11-091002-01

CENTRAL-ALLIED ENTERPRISES INC
Year: 2010
District: 11
Project Number: 090139
PID Number: 25545
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim: 11-090139-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: COL - US-62-4.86
Description: Disposition of Improperly Place RPMs
Issues: Past practice, Workmanlike construction, Acceptance (express/implied)
Decision/Recommendation: 11-090139-01

KARVO PAVING COMPANY
Year: 2010
District: 12
Project Number: 070080
PID Number: 19181
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim: 12-070080-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: GEA - USR 422 - 18.31/0.00
Description: Bridge Deck Repair Costs
Issues: ODOT Testing Procedures, Responsibility for project
Decision/Recommendation: 12-070080-02

ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR/GREAT LAKES CONST - JV
Year: 2010
District: 12
Project Number: 080597
PID Number: 13486
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim: 12-080597-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LAK - SR-2-3.32
Description: Excavation of Subgrade
Issues: Changed contract condition, Equitable Adjustment, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity
Decision/Recommendation: 12-080597-02

ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR/GREAT LAKES CONST - JV
Year: 2010
District: 12
Project Number: 080597
PID Number: 13486
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim: 12-080597-06
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LAK - SR-2-3.32
Description: Additional Costs for Compaction of 304 Material
Issues: Inspection, Changed contract condition, Precaution against damage
Decision/Recommendation: 12-080597-06

ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR/GREAT LAKES CONST - JV
Year: 2010
District: 12
Project Number: 080597
PID Number: 13486
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim: 12-080597-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LAK - SR-2-3.32
Description: Excavation of Subgrade - plans show excavation in one area - ODOT ordered work done in different area
Issues: Signif. change in scope/character of work, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Entitlement agreed/damages in dispute
Decision/Recommendation: 12-080597-02

ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR/GREAT LAKES CONST - JV
Year: 2010
District: 12
Project Number: 080597
PID Number: 13486
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim: 12-080597-05
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LAK - SR-2-3.32
Description: Dowel Bar Inserter Spec Change
Issues: Means and methods, Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Acceptance (express/implied), Past practice
Decision/Recommendation: 12-080597-05

ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR/GREAT LAKES CONST - JV
Year: 2010
District: 12
Project Number: 080597
PID Number: 13486
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim: 12-080597-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LAK - SR-2-3.32
Description: SS888 Aggregate mix design
Issues: Defective specification, Duty to examine Bid Documents, Contract interpretation/ambiguity
Decision/Recommendation: 12-080597-03

KARVO PAVING COMPANY
Year: 2010
District: 12
Project Number: 070002
PID Number: 12999
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim: 12-070002-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - IR 480 - 6.78 (Cities of Brookpark, Cleveland & Fairview Park)
Description: Repair of cracks in concrete pavement (ramp)
Issues: Workmanlike construction, Burden of proof
Decision/Recommendation: 12-070002-01

KARVO PAVING COMPANY
Year: 2010
District: 12
Project Number: 070080
PID Number: 19181
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim: 12-070080-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: GEA - USR 422 - 18.31/0.00
Description: Replacement of Deck Wearing Surface due to failing material
Issues: Inspection, Non-responsiveness as approval/acceptance, Responsibility for project