Issue: Workmanlike construction

ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR INC
Year: 2008
District: 12
Project Number: 078007
PID Number: 22907
Specification Year:
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-078007-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's
Location: LAK - SR 86 - 1.32
Description: Foundation Rock Socket
Issues: Differing site conditions, Workmanlike construction,
Decision/Recommendation: 12-078007-01

CENTRAL-ALLIED ENTERPRISES INC
Year: 2010
District: 11
Project Number: 090139
PID Number: 25545
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 11-090139-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's
Location: COL - US-62-4.86
Description: Disposition of Improperly Place RPMs
Issues: Past practice, Workmanlike construction, Acceptance (express/implied),
Decision/Recommendation: 11-090139-01

GREAT LAKES CONSTRUCTION CO
Year: 2007
District: 2
Project Number: 040584
PID Number: 23956
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 02-040584-01 and -02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's
Location: OTT - SR 2-28.47/0.00
Description: contractor used dry construction method to place concrete in drilled shaft even though wet method should have been used. ODOT required contractor to remove and replace drilled shaft or prove it met strenght requirements. Contractor replaced and requests compensation for extra work
Issues: Drilled shafts, Inspection, Workmanlike construction,
Decision/Recommendation: 02-040584-01 and -02

KARVO PAVING COMPANY
Year: 2010
District: 12
Project Number: 070002
PID Number: 12999
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-070002-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's
Location: CUY - IR 480 - 6.78 (Cities of Brookpark, Cleveland & Fairview Park)
Description: Repair of cracks in concrete pavement (ramp)
Issues: Workmanlike construction, Burden of proof,
Decision/Recommendation: 12-070002-01

KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2005
District: 3
Project Number: 049077
PID Number: 78096
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 03-049077-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Dir
Location: MRW - IR 71 - 19.54/0.00
Description: Joint Repairs
Issues: Dispute Resolution Process, Type A Emergency, Inspection, Acceptance (express/implied), Workmanlike construction, Responsibility for project, Burden of proof,
Decision/Recommendation: 03-049077-01

KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2007
District: 7
Project Number: 030100
PID Number: 19070
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 07-030100-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's
Location: MOT - IR 75 - 31.842 (City of Vandalia)
Description: Bridge Painting - Pinholing
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Reasonably close conformity, Defective specification, Workmanlike construction, Bridge painting, Past practice,
Decision/Recommendation: 07-030100-01

MAHAN/NATIONAL A JOINT VENTURE
Year: 2006
District: 10
Project Number: 020510
PID Number: 19714
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-020510-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Re
Location: MEG - USR 33-15.70 (Village of Pomeroy)
Description: Tower Leg Concrete
Issues: Defective specification, Means and methods, Workmanlike construction, Burden of proof, Changed contract condition,
Decision/Recommendation: 10-020510-02

NATIONAL ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING COMPANY
Year: 2010
District: 6
Project Number: 040163
PID Number: 77003
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040163-07
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's
Location: FRA - SR 161/IR 270-25.900/40.260-Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: Failure of 1500 mm pipe
Issues: Workmanlike construction, Defective specification, Delay - owner caused, Pipe removal,
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040163-07

NATIONAL ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING COMPANY
Year: 2010
District: 6
Project Number: 040163
PID Number: 77003
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040163-09
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's
Location: FRA - SR 161/IR 270-25.900/40.260-Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: Failing Epoxy Urethane Sealer
Issues: Defective specification, Workmanlike construction, Precaution against damage,
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040163-09

SHELLY & SANDS INC
Year: 2010
District: 11
Project Number: 091002
PID Number: 84342
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 11-091002-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's
Location: HAS - SR-9-9.38
Description: Disposition of Improperly Placed RPMs
Issues: Workmanlike construction, Acceptance (express/implied), Past practice,
Decision/Recommendation: 11-091002-01

VELOTTA COMPANY
Year: 2008
District: 4
Project Number: 030534
PID Number: 21004
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-030543-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's
Location: POR - IR 76 - 9.50
Description: Temporary Pavement Repairs
Issues: Contractor proposed change, Workmanlike construction,
Decision/Recommendation: 04-030543-02

WOLF CREEK ENGINEERING AND CONTRACTING INC
Year: 2008
District: 4
Project Number: 060440
PID Number: 23705
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-060440-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's
Location: SUM - IR 277 - 2.47 (City of Akron)
Description: Structural Steel Bolt Replacement
Issues: Burden of proof, Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Means and methods, Workmanlike construction,
Decision/Recommendation: 04-060440-01