District 2
MILLER BROS CONST INC
Year: 2003
Project Number: 990141
PID Number: 9159
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 02-0141(99)-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: LUC - S.R. 2 - 21.24 PART 1; S.R. 2 - 27.26 (JERUSALEM ROAD) PART 2 (City of Oregon)
Description: Asphalt Pavement Rutting
Issues: Asphalt pavement rutting
Decision/Recommendation: 02-0141(99)-02

District 2
POSEN CONSTRUCTION INC
Year: 2010
Project Number: 098019
PID Number: 25555
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 02-098019-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: WOO - IR/LUC-75-32.68/0.00
Description: Extra Hydro-demolition work due to thicker overlay on deck than shown on plans
Issues: Differing site conditions, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Entitlement agreed/damages in dispute
Decision/Recommendation: 02-098019-01

District 2
GREAT LAKES CONSTRUCTION CO
Year: 2007
Project Number: 040584
PID Number: 23956
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 02-040584-01 and -02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: OTT - SR 2-28.47/0.00
Description: contractor used dry construction method to place concrete in drilled shaft even though wet method should have been used. ODOT required contractor to remove and replace drilled shaft or prove it met strenght requirements. Contractor replaced and requests compensation for extra work
Issues: Drilled shafts, Inspection, Workmanlike construction
Decision/Recommendation: 02-040584-01 and -02

District 2
FRU-CON CONSTRUCTION CORPORATION
Year: 2004
Project Number: 010493
PID Number: 20208
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: D2.025
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: LUC - IR 280 - 2.96
Description: Discrepancy in Concrete Quantity for Precast Segmental Concrete
Issues: Discrepancy in quantity, Signif. change in scope/character of work, Notice
Decision/Recommendation: D2.025

District 2
MILLER BROS CONST INC
Year: 2002
Project Number: 990141
PID Number: 9159
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 02-0141(99)-0901-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: LUC - S.R. 2 - 21.24 PART 1; S.R. 2 - 27.26 (JERUSALEM ROAD) PART 2 (City of Oregon)
Description: Brick Salvage Value, Various Additional Costs
Decision/Recommendation: 02-0141(99)-0901-01

District 3
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2005
Project Number: 049077
PID Number: 78096
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 03-049077-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: MRW - IR 71 - 19.54/0.00
Description: Joint Repairs
Issues: Dispute Resolution Process, Type A Emergency, Inspection, Acceptance (express/implied), Workmanlike construction, Responsibility for project, Burden of proof
Decision/Recommendation: 03-049077-01

District 3
RUHLIN COMPANY
Year: 2007
Project Number: 040082
PID Number: 18631
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 03-040082-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: WAY - USR 30/250-9.18/9.98 (City of Wooster)
Description: excavation and embankment - differing site conditions, undercuts, plan errors
Issues: Differing site conditions, Equitable Adjustment, Errors and Omissions, Signif. change in scope/character of work
Decision/Recommendation: 03-040082-01

District 3
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 050343
PID Number: 14018
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 03-050343-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: MED - IR 71-9.56
Description: Value Engineering Participation
Issues: Value Engineering Proposal, Contract interpretation/ambiguity
Decision/Recommendation: 03-050343-01

District 3
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 050343
PID Number: 14018
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 03-050343-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: MED - IR 71-9.56
Description: Delay Costs due to Delay in VE response
Issues: CPM Progress Schedule, Change order policy, Delay - owner caused
Decision/Recommendation: 03-050343-02

District 3
COSMOS INDUSTRIAL SERVICES INC
Year: 2012
Project Number: 110155
PID Number: 81374
Specification Year: 2010
Dispute/Claim Number: 03-110155-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LOR - VA-BH-FY2011
Description: Maintenance of Traffic Pay Items
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity
Decision/Recommendation: 03-110155-01

District 3
SPECIALIZED CONSTRUCTION INC
Year: 2010
Project Number: 080477
PID Number: 80050
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 03-080477-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CRA - VA-CHIP-FY2009
Description: Chip Seal Warranty
Issues: Warranty, Acceptance (express/implied)
Decision/Recommendation: 03-080477-01

District 3
BECDIR CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2012
Project Number: 076004
PID Number: 13136
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 03-076004-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: ERI - USR 250 - 19.742 (12.43) (Village of Milan)
Description: Final Quantities - Pavement Removed, Aggregate Base, Removal of Pavement Markings, Beam Seat Repair
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Discrepancy in quantity, Method of Measurement
Decision/Recommendation: 03-076004-03

District 3
MOSSER CONSTRUCTION INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 060216
PID Number: 23504
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 03-060216-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Arbitration
Location: RIC - CR 424-0.62
Description: Removal of Granular Embankment
Issues: Acceptance (express/implied), ODOT Testing Procedures
Decision/Recommendation: 03-060216-01

District 3
RUHLIN COMPANY
Year: 2007
Project Number: 040082
PID Number: 18631
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 03-040082-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: WAY - USR 30/250-9.18/9.98 (City of Wooster)
Description: Payment of granular embankment
Issues: Burden of proof, Discrepancy in quantity
Decision/Recommendation: 03-040082-03

District 3
RUHLIN COMPANY
Year: 2007
Project Number: 040082
PID Number: 18631
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 03-040082-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: WAY - USR 30/250-9.18/9.98 (City of Wooster)
Description: requesting return of liquidated damages, additional costs for MOT due to
Issues: Delay - owner caused, Duty to coordinate subs, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity
Decision/Recommendation: 03-040082-02

District 4
VELOTTA COMPANY
Year: 2005
Project Number: 030534
PID Number: 21004
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-030534-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: POR - IR 76 - 9.50
Description: Fabrication of Structural Steel Plate Girders
Issues: Constructive acceleration, Unjust enrichment, Equitable Adjustment, Early Completion Schedule, Mitigation, Duty to coordinate subs, Voluntary Acceleration
Decision/Recommendation: 04-030534-01

District 4
WOLF CREEK ENGINEERING AND CONTRACTING INC
Year: 2008
Project Number: 060441
PID Number: 23702
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-060441-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: SUM - SR 21 - (2.60 Greenwich Rd.) (4.62 Reimer Rd.)
Description: Structural Steel Price Escalation due to Sole Source
Issues: Burden of proof, Material escalation
Decision/Recommendation: 04-060441-01

District 4
WOLF CREEK ENGINEERING AND CONTRACTING INC
Year: 2008
Project Number: 060440
PID Number: 23705
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-060440-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: SUM - IR 277 - 2.47 (City of Akron)
Description: Structural Steel Bolt Replacement
Issues: Burden of proof, Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Means and methods, Workmanlike construction
Decision/Recommendation: 04-060440-01

District 4
VELOTTA COMPANY
Year: 2008
Project Number: 030534
PID Number: 21004
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-030534-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: POR - IR 76 - 9.50
Description: Form Safety Stop Removal
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Extra work
Decision/Recommendation: 04-030534-03

District 4
VELOTTA COMPANY
Year: 2008
Project Number: 030534
PID Number: 21004
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-030534-04
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: POR - IR 76 - 9.50
Description: "Over Inspection" of Bridge Painting
Issues: Bridge painting, Burden of proof, Changed contract condition
Decision/Recommendation: 04-030534-04

District 4
ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR/GREAT LAKES CONST - JV
Year: 2008
Project Number: 060002
PID Number: 6080
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-060002-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: MAH - I R 80 - 0.97
Description: Industry Wide Claim Shortage
Issues: Duty to coordinate subs, Industry-wide shortage/impacts
Decision/Recommendation: 04-060002-01

District 4
VELOTTA COMPANY
Year: 2008
Project Number: 030534
PID Number: 21004
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-030543-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: POR - IR 76 - 9.50
Description: Temporary Pavement Repairs
Issues: Contractor proposed change, Workmanlike construction
Decision/Recommendation: 04-030543-02

District 4
NORTHERN OHIO PAVING COMPANY
Year: 2002
Project Number: 013002
PID Number: 22163
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-3002(01)-1119-04
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: TRU - IR 80 - 9.08
Description: Repair of Bridge Overlay
Decision/Recommendation: 04-3002(01)-1119-04

District 4
TRI SPAN CORPORATION
Year: 2009
Project Number: 080001
PID Number: 77345
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-080001-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: ATB - IR-90-5.37;ATB-46-21.95
Description: Additional Embankment Costs due to Improper Testing
Issues: ODOT Testing Procedures, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Means and methods, Responsibility for project
Decision/Recommendation: 04-080001-01

District 4
VELOTTA COMPANY
Year: 1999
Project Number: 940613
PID Number: 4185
Specification Year:
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-0613(94)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Arbitration
Location: Summit County
Description: Additional Costs of Painting Operations, Excess Sandblasting, Excess Materials
Issues: Bridge painting, Reasonably close conformity, Inspection
Decision/Recommendation: 04-0613(94)-01

District 4
GREAT LAKES CONSTRUCTION CO
Year: 2003
Project Number: 000323
PID Number: 13458
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-0323(00)-1102-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: SUM - IR 76 - 24.799/0.000 (Cities of Akron & Tallmadge)
Description: Thin Pavement
Issues: Thin concrete pavement, Unjust enrichment
Decision/Recommendation: 04-0323(00)-1102-02

District 4
GREAT LAKES CONSTRUCTION CO
Year: 2003
Project Number: 000323
PID Number: 13458
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-0323(00)-1102-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: SUM - IR 76 - 24.799/0.000 (Cities of Akron & Tallmadge)
Description: Concrete Pavement with Warranty
Issues: Concrete pavement w/warranty
Decision/Recommendation: 04-0323(00)-1102-01

District 4
SHELLY & SANDS INC
Year: 2004
Project Number: 030406
PID Number: 23412
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-0406(03)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: POR - SR 303 - 2.73 (City of Streetsboro)
Description: Partial Depth Repairs
Issues: Signif. change in scope/character of work, Partial Depth Pavement Repair
Decision/Recommendation: 04-0406(03)-01

District 4
VELOTTA COMPANY
Year: 2008
Project Number: 030534
PID Number: 21004
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-030534-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Arbitration
Location: POR - IR 76 - 9.50
Description: Temporary Pavement Repairs
Issues: Burden of proof, Contract interpretation/ambiguity
Decision/Recommendation: 04-030534-02

District 4
SODA CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2002
Project Number: 990181
PID Number: 4130
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-0181(99)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: MAH - S.R. 616 - 4.973 (City of Struthers)
Description: Compensation for Breach of Contract, Misc.
Decision/Recommendation: 04-0181(99)-01

District 5
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2000
Project Number: 970139
PID Number: 14143
Specification Year:
Dispute/Claim Number: 05-0139(97)-0897-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: COS - USR 36 - 27.54
Description: Pipe Removal Payment
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Pipe removal, Pre-bid question
Decision/Recommendation: 05-0139(97)-0897-03

District 5
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2001
Project Number: 970139
PID Number: 14143
Specification Year:
Dispute/Claim Number: 05-0139(97)-0897-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Arbitration
Location: COS - USR 36 - 27.54
Description: Pipe Removal Payment
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Pipe removal, Pre-bid question
Decision/Recommendation: 05-0139(97)-0897-03

District 5
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2007
Project Number: 023005
PID Number: 19821
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 05-023005-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: GUE - IR 77 - 7.54/7.68
Description: Significant Changes in the Scope of Work
Issues: Reasonably close conformity, Signif. change in scope/character of work, Change order release/waiver, Unjust enrichment, Inspection
Decision/Recommendation: 05-023005-03

District 5
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2007
Project Number: 023005
PID Number: 19821
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 05-023005-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: GUE - IR 77 - 7.54/7.68
Description: Bridge Painting - Painting Platform
Issues: Contractor proposed change, Change order release/waiver, Notice, Mitigation, Duty to coordinate subs
Decision/Recommendation: 05-023005-02

District 5
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2007
Project Number: 023005
PID Number: 19821
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 05-023005-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: GUE - IR 77 - 7.54/7.68
Description: Bridge Painting - High Profile
Issues: Specifications (design/performance), Bridge painting, Past practice, Defective specification
Decision/Recommendation: 05-023005-01

District 5
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2004
Project Number: 020068
PID Number: 13281
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 05-0068(02)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: FAI - USR 33 - 0.41 (City of Springdale)
Description: Ameritech Utility Delay
Issues: Utility delay, CPM Progress Schedule, Non-responsiveness as approval/acceptance, Overhead (home/field office), Extra work, Notice, Delay - critical/non-critical, CPM calendar/logic changes
Decision/Recommendation: 05-0068(02)-01

District 5
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 070138
PID Number: 77221
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 05-070138-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LIC - SR 161/37 - 6.65/10.25
Description: Value Engineering
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Contractor proposed change
Decision/Recommendation: 05-070138-01

District 6
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2003
Project Number: 020069
PID Number: 4666
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-0069(02)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: FRA - IR 670 - 3.17/Various - Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: Drilled Shafts and Tie Backs
Issues: Differing site conditions, Drilled shafts, Tie back retaining walls, Means and methods, Winter protection
Decision/Recommendation: 06-0069(02)-01

District 6
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 040294
PID Number: 77118
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040294-05
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CLA - IR 70-25.11/28.95/29.32/0.00 - Part 1, 2 & 3
Description: Material escalation for steel and geo-textile fabric. When project was bid these materials were experiencing large price escalations. Due to this volatility price quotes for this material were only firm through 9/30/04 for piling and 12/31/05 for the geotextile fabric. The contractor was delayed 45 days due to extra work.
Issues: Material escalation, Industry standard
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040294-05

District 6
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 040294
PID Number: 77118
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040294-04
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CLA - IR 70-25.11/28.95/29.32/0.00 - Part 1, 2 & 3
Description: This project was sold with no provision for a fuel price adjustment. In 2005 ODOT established a fuel price adjustment policy and allowed for such adjustments on ongoing projects and extended that until 2006. The Contractor is asking for the adjustment for work it did in 2007.
Issues: Delay - owner caused, Industry standard, Material escalation
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040294-04

District 6
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 040294
PID Number: 77118
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040294-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CLA - IR 70-25.11/28.95/29.32/0.00 - Part 1, 2 & 3
Description: Contractor is seeking $223, 560 for home and field overhead for the winter of 2006/2007. This was a workday contract rather than a completion date contract.
Issues: Delay - owner caused, Overhead (home/field office)
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040294-03

District 6
SHELLY & SANDS INC
Year: 2013
Project Number: 110341
PID Number: 76191
Specification Year: 2010
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-110341-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: FRA - IR-270-2.60
Description: Shop Applied Paint
Issues: Acceptance (express/implied), Bridge painting, Burden of proof, Duty to coordinate subs, ODOT Testing Procedures
Decision/Recommendation: 06-110341-01

District 6
NATIONAL ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING COMPANY
Year: 2006
Project Number: 040163
PID Number: 77003
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040163-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: FRA - SR 161/IR 270-25.900/40.260-Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: Multiple Project Impacts
Issues: Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Utility delay, Delay - owner caused, Constructive acceleration, Extra work, Change order release/waiver, Winter protection, Overhead (home/field office)
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040163-03

District 6
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 040294
PID Number: 77118
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040294-06
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CLA - IR 70-25.11/28.95/29.32/0.00 - Part 1, 2 & 3
Description: This project used a workday contract in lieu of a completion date contract. Parties agree to 45 days of extra work and 102 days of weather. Kokosing is seeking site rental costs for land leased for their portable plant ($8,727.12) and for labor escalation ($10,182.05) for extension of the contract into 2007.
Issues: Delay - owner caused, Material escalation
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040294-06

District 6
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 040294
PID Number: 77118
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040294-07
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CLA - IR 70-25.11/28.95/29.32/0.00 - Part 1, 2 & 3
Description: Extra costs to "level up" median embankment - an error in the plan caused an elevation differential that had to be eliminated by embankment to prevent a drop off. District stated almost none of the median had been acceptably final graded. District also stated the operation of grading no different in planned profile areas vs. changed profile areas. Contractor presented a measured mile approach to show inefficiency.
Issues: Signif. change in scope/character of work
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040294-07

District 6
JOHN R JURGENSEN COMPANY
Year: 2006
Project Number: 030134
PID Number: 6225
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: n/a
Dispute Resolution Forum:
Location: FAY - IR 71 - 0.00 (Villages of Octa & Jeffersonville)
Description: High Performance Concrete For New Bridge Decks With Warranty Appeal
Issues: Warranty
Decision/Recommendation: n/a

District 6
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 040294
PID Number: 77118
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040294-08
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CLA - IR 70-25.11/28.95/29.32/0.00 - Part 1, 2 & 3
Description: Contractor wants paid permanent seeding for additional locations: two off-site waste areas, an off-site area where temporary plant was located and an area it placed waste within the highway ROW. Areas totalled 69,819 SY.
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Discrepancy in quantity
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040294-08

District 6
NATIONAL ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING COMPANY
Year: 2005
Project Number: 040163
PID Number: 77003
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-0163(04)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: FRA - SR 161/IR 270-25.900/40.260-Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: MSE Wall Backfill Resistivity Testing
Issues: Mutual Mistake, Unjust enrichment, Reasonably close conformity, Industry standard, Past practice, Contract interpretation/ambiguity, MSE wall
Decision/Recommendation: 06-0163(04)-01

District 6
NATIONAL ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING COMPANY
Year: 2010
Project Number: 040163
PID Number: 77003
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040163-09
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: FRA - SR 161/IR 270-25.900/40.260-Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: Failing Epoxy Urethane Sealer
Issues: Defective specification, Workmanlike construction, Precaution against damage
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040163-09

District 6
NATIONAL ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING COMPANY
Year: 2010
Project Number: 040163
PID Number: 77003
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040163-07
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: FRA - SR 161/IR 270-25.900/40.260-Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: Failure of 1500 mm pipe
Issues: Workmanlike construction, Defective specification, Delay - owner caused, Pipe removal
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040163-07

District 6
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2008
Project Number: 060264
PID Number: 77467
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-060264-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: FRA - USR 62-14.11 (Main Street)
Description: Transportation Delay Claim
Issues: Delay - owner caused, Means and methods, Past practice
Decision/Recommendation: 06-060264-03

District 6
SHELLY & SANDS INC
Year: 2011
Project Number: 080080
PID Number: 81190
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-080080-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: PIC - US-23-10.38 AND VARIOUS
Description: Railroad Delay
Issues: Burden of proof, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Railroad Conflict
Decision/Recommendation: 06-080080-01

District 6
Perram Electric
Year: 2012
Project Number: 100345
PID Number: 87884
Specification Year: 2010
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-100389-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: District 6 various
Description: Pole Clamps for Tether Wire Five Projects in Four Districts
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity
Decision/Recommendation: 12-100389-01

District 6
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2007
Project Number: 060264
PID Number: 77467
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-060264-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: FRA - USR 62-14.11 (Main Street)
Description: High Water
Issues: Act of God, Contract interpretation/ambiguity
Decision/Recommendation: 06-060264-01

District 6
NATIONAL ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING COMPANY
Year: 2005
Project Number: 040163
PID Number: 77003
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-0163(04)-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: FRA - SR 161/IR 270-25.900/40.260-Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: MSE Wall Design Criteria
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, MSE wall, Incorporation by reference
Decision/Recommendation: 06-0163(04)-02

District 6
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2008
Project Number: 060162
PID Number: 75904
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-060162-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: FRA - IR 71-7.68 (Hoover Rd.)
Description: Pinholing
Issues: Bridge painting, Defective specification, Duty to coordinate subs, Industry standard, Means and methods
Decision/Recommendation: 06-060162-01

District 6
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 040294
PID Number: 77118
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040294-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CLA - IR 70-25.11/28.95/29.32/0.00 - Part 1, 2 & 3
Description: Interest on untimely processing of Change Orders 60, 63 and 65.
Issues: Interest, Change order policy
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040294-01

District 6
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2011
Project Number: 101039
PID Number: 80721
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-101039-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: FRA - IR-270-37.04
Description: Method of Payment of Topsoil in a Median Planter
Issues: Method of Measurement, Burden of proof
Decision/Recommendation: 06-101039-01

District 6
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 040294
PID Number: 77118
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040294-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CLA - IR 70-25.11/28.95/29.32/0.00 - Part 1, 2 & 3
Description: Asphalt for MOT - contractor is seeking payment for asphalt used to transition between pavements at different elevations.
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040294-02

District 7
R B JERGENS CONTRACTORS INC
Year: 2013
Project Number: 091060
PID Number: 80236
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 07-091060-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: MOT - LR-SOUTH DIXIE-PHASE 2
Description: Final Quantity Dispute - 304 base and asphalt surface course
Issues: Discrepancy in quantity, Signif. change in scope/character of work, Means and methods
Decision/Recommendation: 07-091060-02

District 7
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2007
Project Number: 030100
PID Number: 19070
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 07-030100-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: MOT - IR 75 - 31.842 (City of Vandalia)
Description: Bridge Painting - Pinholing
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Reasonably close conformity, Defective specification, Workmanlike construction, Bridge painting, Past practice
Decision/Recommendation: 07-030100-01

District 7
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 060036
PID Number: 17067
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 07-060036-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: MOT - USR 35-15.07
Description: Early Notice of Excessive & Improper Enforcement
Issues: Dispute Resolution Process, Notice, Overhead (home/field office), Signif. change in scope/character of work
Decision/Recommendation: 07-060036-02

District 7
R B JERGENS CONTRACTORS INC
Year: 2011
Project Number: 091060
PID Number: 80236
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 07-091060-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: MOT - LR-SOUTH DIXIE-PHASE 2
Description: Delays - due to utility - due to ODOT delay in scheduling pre-con - due to poor subgrade
Issues: Delay - owner caused, Overhead (home/field office), Burden of proof, CPM Progress Schedule, Utility delay
Decision/Recommendation: 07-091060-01

District 7
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2004
Project Number: 010560
PID Number: 18249
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 07-0560(01)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: MOT - IR 75-29.305
Description: Ameritech Utility Delay
Issues: Utility delay, Mitigation, Notice, CPM Progress Schedule
Decision/Recommendation: 07-0560(01)-01

District 7
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 070387
PID Number: 75927
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 07-070387-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: MOT - IR-75-13.11
Description: Sleeper Slab Concrete and Coping
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Means and methods, Mitigation, Pre-bid question
Decision/Recommendation: 07-070387-01

District 8
A & A SAFETY INC
Year: 2013
Project Number: 120233
PID Number: 87018
Specification Year: 2010
Dispute/Claim Number: 08-120233-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: BUT - VA-PM/RPM-FY2012
Description: Center Line Marking Final Quantity
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Method of Measurement, Past practice
Decision/Recommendation: 08-120233-01

District 8
JOHN R JURGENSEN COMPANY
Year: 2000
Project Number: 003012
PID Number: 19786
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 08-3012(00)-0201-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Arbitration
Location: HAM - IR 275 - 32.27/0.00 (Cities of Montgomery & Milford) (Village of Indian Hill)
Description: Design-Build Scope of Work - Temporary Shoring
Issues: Design-Build, Specifications (design/performance), Contract interpretation/ambiguity
Decision/Recommendation: 08-3012(00)-0201-02

District 8
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2002
Project Number: 010158
PID Number: 6525
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 08-0158(01)-0102-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: HAM - SR 4-4.000 (Paddock Road) (City of Cincinnati)
Description: Extent of Repair/Removal of Honeycomb Concrete
Decision/Recommendation: 08-0158(01)-0102-01

District 8
DOUBLE Z CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2008
Project Number: 050497
PID Number: 22379
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 08-050497-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CLE - USR 52-7.81/15.44/20.67
Description: Unclassified Excavation
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Discrepancy in quantity, Errors and Omissions
Decision/Recommendation: 08-050497-01

District 8
JOHN R JURGENSEN COMPANY
Year: 2005
Project Number: 030002
PID Number: 17381
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 08-030002-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: BUT - CR 115 - 0.00 (City of Fairfield)
Description: Concrete Testing and Inspection
Issues: Notice, Duty to examine Bid Documents, Errors and Omissions, Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Signif. change in scope/character of work, Mitigation, Duty to coordinate subs, Equitable Adjustment
Decision/Recommendation: 08-030002-01

District 9
ALAN STONE CO INC
Year: 2013
Project Number: 120251
PID Number: 91276
Specification Year: 2010
Dispute/Claim Number: 09-120251-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LAW - SR-378-0.20
Description: Water in Drilled Shafts
Issues: Drilled shafts, Differing site conditions, Interest, Contract interpretation/ambiguity
Decision/Recommendation: 09-120251-01

District 9
ICARUS INDUSTRIAL PAINTING & CONTRACTING CO INC
Year: 2002
Project Number: 990465
PID Number: 19781
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 09-0465(99)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: JAC - S.R. 32 - 11.75/VARIOUS (City of Ironton) (Village of Hanging Rock)
Description: Bridge Painting
Issues: Dispute Resolution Process, Bridge painting
Decision/Recommendation: 09-0465(99)-01

District 9
C J MAHAN CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LLC
Year: 2002
Project Number: 010178
PID Number: 11858
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 09-0178(01)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: SCI - USR 23-0.00 (City of Portsmouth)
Description: Erection Engineering Delay and Cost
Issues: CPM Progress Schedule, Delay - owner caused, Errors and Omissions
Decision/Recommendation: 09-0178(01)-01

District 9
C J MAHAN CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LLC
Year: 2008
Project Number: 010178
PID Number: 11858
Specification Year:
Dispute/Claim Number: 09-010178-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Arbitration
Location: SCI - USR 23-0.00 (City of Portsmouth)
Description: Baffle Plate Dispute
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Acceptance (express/implied)
Decision/Recommendation: 09-010178-02

District 10
MAHAN/NATIONAL A JOINT VENTURE
Year: 2009
Project Number: 020510
PID Number: 19714
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-020510-4 and 5
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: MEG - USR 33-15.70 (Village of Pomeroy)
Description: Retaining Wall Concrete Quantity and Retaining Wall Sealing Quantity
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Contractor proposed change, Discrepancy in quantity
Decision/Recommendation: 10-020510-4 and 5

District 10
BEAVER EXCAVATING COMPANY
Year: 2008
Project Number: 060132
PID Number: 75812
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-060132-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: MEG - USR 33-9.40; SR 7-6.17 - Part 1 & 2
Description: Concrete Pavement Cracking
Issues: Defective specification, Contractor proposed change, Means and methods, Specifications (design/performance)
Decision/Recommendation: 10-060132-01

District 10
MAHAN/NATIONAL A JOINT VENTURE
Year: 2009
Project Number: 020510
PID Number: 19714
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-020510-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: MEG - USR 33-15.70 (Village of Pomeroy)
Description: P-T Air Testing Quantum Only
Issues: CPM calendar/logic changes, Delay - critical/non-critical, Delay - owner caused, Entitlement agreed/damages in dispute, Mutual Mistake
Decision/Recommendation: 10-020510-01

District 10
SMITH & JOHNSON CONSTRUCTION CO
Year: 2002
Project Number: 010246
PID Number: 18288
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-0246(01)-0402-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: ATH - USR 33 - 40.981
Description: Timber Value & Production Loss
Decision/Recommendation: 10-0246(01)-0402-02

District 10
MAHAN/NATIONAL A JOINT VENTURE
Year: 2007
Project Number: 020510
PID Number: 19714
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-020510-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: MEG - USR 33-15.70 (Village of Pomeroy)
Description: Concrete Quality in Tower Segment Four
Decision/Recommendation: 10-020510-02

District 10
MAHAN/NATIONAL A JOINT VENTURE
Year: 2007
Project Number: 020510
PID Number: 19714
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-020510-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: MEG - USR 33-15.70 (Village of Pomeroy)
Description: Post tension duct air test specification
Issues: Changed contract condition
Decision/Recommendation: 10-020510-01

District 10
SMITH & JOHNSON CONSTRUCTION CO
Year: 2004
Project Number: 010246
PID Number: 18288
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-0246(01)-0402-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: ATH - USR 33 - 40.981
Description: Timber Value & Production Loss
Decision/Recommendation: 10-0246(01)-0402-02

District 10
BECDIR CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2004
Project Number: 020236
PID Number: 23900
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-0236(02)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Arbitration
Location: VIN - CR 38A - 0.36/Various
Description: Covered Bridges
Issues: Constructive acceleration, Mitigation, Precaution against damage, Act of God, Dispute Resolution Process, Claim after final change order, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Delay - owner caused
Decision/Recommendation: 10-0236(02)-01

District 10
R C CONSTRUCTION COMPANY AND SON INC
Year: 2008
Project Number: 060322
PID Number: 76229
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-060322-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: VIN - USR 50-0.10
Description: Off Site Borrow
Issues: Burden of proof, Entitlement agreed/damages in dispute, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Means and methods
Decision/Recommendation: 10-060322-01

District 10
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2002
Project Number: 013001
PID Number: 21053
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-3001(01)-1001-04
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: ATH - USR 33 - 10.41
Description: Project Completion Delay - HOOH, Extended Cost
Issues: Engineer-ordered suspension, Extra work, Change order policy, Interest, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity
Decision/Recommendation: 10-3001(01)-1001-04

District 10
MAHAN/NATIONAL A JOINT VENTURE
Year: 2006
Project Number: 020510
PID Number: 19714
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-020510-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: MEG - USR 33-15.70 (Village of Pomeroy)
Description: Tower Leg Concrete
Issues: Defective specification, Means and methods, Workmanlike construction, Burden of proof, Changed contract condition
Decision/Recommendation: 10-020510-02

District 10
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2003
Project Number: 013001
PID Number: 21053
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-3001(01)-1001-04
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: ATH - USR 33 - 10.41
Description: Project Completion Delay - HOOH, Extended Cost
Issues: Engineer-ordered suspension, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Overhead (home/field office), Extra work, Change order policy, Interest
Decision/Recommendation: 10-3001(01)-1001-04

District 11
SHELLY & SANDS INC
Year: 2010
Project Number: 091002
PID Number: 84342
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 11-091002-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: HAS - SR-9-9.38
Description: Disposition of Improperly Placed RPMs
Issues: Workmanlike construction, Acceptance (express/implied), Past practice
Decision/Recommendation: 11-091002-01

District 11
A P O'HORO COMPANY
Year: 2010
Project Number: 080618
PID Number: 80116
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 11-080618-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: COL - SR-164-21.81
Description: Method of Measurement of Composite Fiber Wrap System
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Duty to examine Bid Documents, Past practice
Decision/Recommendation: 11-080618-01

District 11
CENTRAL-ALLIED ENTERPRISES INC
Year: 2010
Project Number: 090139
PID Number: 25545
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 11-090139-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: COL - US-62-4.86
Description: Disposition of Improperly Place RPMs
Issues: Past practice, Workmanlike construction, Acceptance (express/implied)
Decision/Recommendation: 11-090139-01

District 12
ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR/GREAT LAKES CONST - JV
Year: 2010
Project Number: 080597
PID Number: 13486
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-080597-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LAK - SR-2-3.32
Description: Excavation of Subgrade - plans show excavation in one area - ODOT ordered work done in different area
Issues: Signif. change in scope/character of work, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Entitlement agreed/damages in dispute
Decision/Recommendation: 12-080597-02

District 12
KARVO PAVING COMPANY
Year: 2010
Project Number: 070002
PID Number: 12999
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-070002-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - IR 480 - 6.78 (Cities of Brookpark, Cleveland & Fairview Park)
Description: Repair of cracks in concrete pavement (ramp)
Issues: Workmanlike construction, Burden of proof
Decision/Recommendation: 12-070002-01

District 12
GERONIMO PAINTING CO INC
Year: 2009
Project Number: 050107
PID Number: 22130
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-050107-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - SR 2 - 14.41 (City of Cleveland)
Description: Testing Equipment
Issues: Inspection, Reasonably close conformity, Entitlement agreed/damages in dispute, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity
Decision/Recommendation: 12-050107-02

District 12
BURTON SCOT CONTRACTORS LLC
Year: 2012
Project Number: 100186
PID Number: 80252
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-100186-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - SR-43-6.18
Description: Home Office Overhead and Inefficiency
Issues: Changed contract condition, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Delay - owner caused, Notice, Signif. change in scope/character of work, Utility delay
Decision/Recommendation: 12-100186-01

District 12
WALSH CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2008
Project Number: 040293
PID Number: 5511
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-040293-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - West 3rd St. (City of Cleveland)
Description: Increased Rigging Costs
Issues: Changed contract condition, Extra work, Entitlement agreed/damages in dispute
Decision/Recommendation: 12-040293-02

District 12
WALSH CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2008
Project Number: 040293
PID Number: 5511
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-040293-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - West 3rd St. (City of Cleveland)
Description: Increased Cleaning Costs
Issues: Changed contract condition, Entitlement agreed/damages in dispute, Signif. change in scope/character of work
Decision/Recommendation: 12-040293-03

District 12
ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR/GREAT LAKES CONST - JV
Year: 2010
Project Number: 080597
PID Number: 13486
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-080597-05
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LAK - SR-2-3.32
Description: Dowel Bar Inserter Spec Change
Issues: Means and methods, Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Acceptance (express/implied), Past practice
Decision/Recommendation: 12-080597-05

District 12
ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR/GREAT LAKES CONST - JV
Year: 2010
Project Number: 080597
PID Number: 13486
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-080597-06
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LAK - SR-2-3.32
Description: Additional Costs for Compaction of 304 Material
Issues: Inspection, Changed contract condition, Precaution against damage
Decision/Recommendation: 12-080597-06

District 12
RUHLIN COMPANY
Year: 2013
Project Number: 101041
PID Number: 86257
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-101041-06
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - LR-WILLOW AVENUE LIFT BRIDGE
Description: Deficient Grating Installation (Open Grid Deck Welding)
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Industry standard, Reasonably close conformity
Decision/Recommendation: 12-101041-06

District 12
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2008
Project Number: 060372
PID Number: 5394
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-060372-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: CUY - Fulton Road (BR-251) (City of Cleveland)
Description: Post Tensioning Duct Air Testing
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Contractor proposed change, Specifications (design/performance)
Decision/Recommendation: 12-060372-02

District 12
GERONIMO PAINTING CO INC
Year: 2006
Project Number: 050107
PID Number: 22130
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-050107-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: CUY - SR 2 - 14.41 (City of Cleveland)
Description: Bridge Painting - Surface Cleanliness
Issues: Inspection, Acceptance (express/implied), Industry standard, Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Mitigation, Bridge painting
Decision/Recommendation: 12-050107-01

District 12
GERONIMO PAINTING CO INC
Year: 2006
Project Number: 050107
PID Number: 22130
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-050107-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: CUY - SR 2 - 14.41 (City of Cleveland)
Description: Bridge Painting - Testing Equipment
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Inspection, Industry standard, Bridge painting
Decision/Recommendation: 12-050107-02

District 12
GERONIMO PAINTING CO INC
Year: 2006
Project Number: 050107
PID Number: 22130
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-050107-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: CUY - SR 2 - 14.41 (City of Cleveland)
Description: Bridge Painting - Heating Costs
Issues: Defective specification, Notice, Mitigation
Decision/Recommendation: 12-050107-03

District 12
GERONIMO PAINTING CO INC
Year: 2006
Project Number: 050107
PID Number: 22130
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-050107-04
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - SR 2 - 14.41 (City of Cleveland)
Description: Fuel Price Escalation
Issues: Material escalation
Decision/Recommendation: 12-050107-04

District 12
WALSH CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2006
Project Number: 040293
PID Number: 5511
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-040293-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - West 3rd St. (City of Cleveland)
Description: Wire Rope Length
Issues: Disclaimer, Errors and Omissions, Shop Drawings, Acceptance (express/implied), Defective specification, Notice, Mitigation
Decision/Recommendation: 12-040293-01

District 12
ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR/GREAT LAKES CONST - JV
Year: 2010
Project Number: 080597
PID Number: 13486
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-080597-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LAK - SR-2-3.32
Description: Excavation of Subgrade
Issues: Changed contract condition, Equitable Adjustment, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity
Decision/Recommendation: 12-080597-02

District 12
RUHLIN COMPANY
Year: 2012
Project Number: 101041
PID Number: 86257
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-101041-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - LR-WILLOW AVENUE LIFT BRIDGE
Description: Aluminum Post modifications
Issues: Duty to examine Bid Documents, Errors and Omissions, Shop Drawings
Decision/Recommendation: 12-101041-01

District 12
ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR/GREAT LAKES CONST - JV
Year: 2010
Project Number: 080597
PID Number: 13486
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-080597-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LAK - SR-2-3.32
Description: SS888 Aggregate mix design
Issues: Defective specification, Duty to examine Bid Documents, Contract interpretation/ambiguity
Decision/Recommendation: 12-080597-03

District 12
RUHLIN COMPANY
Year: 2012
Project Number: 101041
PID Number: 86257
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-101041-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - LR-WILLOW AVENUE LIFT BRIDGE
Description: Sidewalk Bracket and Connection Angles
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity
Decision/Recommendation: 12-101041-02

District 12
SHELLY COMPANY
Year: 2007
Project Number: 060121
PID Number: 12996
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-060121-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - IR 271-6.04
Description: Asphalt concrete bump grinding and mix design changes
Issues: Specifications (design/performance), Means and methods
Decision/Recommendation: 12-060121-01

District 12
ANTHONY ALLEGA CEMENT CONTRACTOR INC
Year: 2008
Project Number: 078007
PID Number: 22907
Specification Year:
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-078007-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: LAK - SR 86 - 1.32
Description: Foundation Rock Socket
Issues: Differing site conditions, Workmanlike construction
Decision/Recommendation: 12-078007-01

District 12
KARVO PAVING COMPANY
Year: 2010
Project Number: 070080
PID Number: 19181
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-070080-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: GEA - USR 422 - 18.31/0.00
Description: Bridge Deck Repair Costs
Issues: ODOT Testing Procedures, Responsibility for project
Decision/Recommendation: 12-070080-02

District 12
KARVO PAVING COMPANY
Year: 2010
Project Number: 070080
PID Number: 19181
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-070080-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: GEA - USR 422 - 18.31/0.00
Description: Replacement of Deck Wearing Surface due to failing material
Issues: Inspection, Non-responsiveness as approval/acceptance, Responsibility for project

District 12
GREAT LAKES CONSTRUCTION CO
Year: 2011
Project Number: 080598
PID Number: 21272
Specification Year: 2005
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-080598-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - SR-237-4.93 - PART I (FRONT STREET); CUY-237-4.55 - PART 2
Description: Railroad Delay - Crane holding girder over live track
Issues: Burden of proof, Delay - critical/non-critical, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Railroad Conflict
Decision/Recommendation: 12-080598-02

District 12
RUHLIN COMPANY
Year: 2012
Project Number: 101041
PID Number: 86257
Specification Year: 2008
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-101041-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - LR-WILLOW AVENUE LIFT BRIDGE
Description: Repair Costs for Shop Coating Defects
Issues: Reasonably close conformity, Inspection, Acceptance (express/implied), Bridge painting
Decision/Recommendation: 12-101041-03