Item 403 ASPHALT CONCRETE QUALITY CONTROL AND ACCEPTANCE
403.03 Quality Control Program (QCP)
403.06 Verification Acceptance (VA)
403.07 Unconditional Acceptance
403.08 Acceptance Tables for 448 Mixes
403.01 Description. This specification outlines the Contractor requirements for controlling asphalt concrete, asphalt concrete base, or other asphalt mixtures as specified.
403.02 General. The Department will determine acceptance by Department Verification Acceptance (VA) tests and monitoring reviews as specified. If the Contractor fails to operate according to its Quality Control Program (QCP), the Department will accept asphalt mixtures by Unconditional Acceptance.
Restoration of VA procedures will be by the Department’s Quality Control Qualification Committee (QCQC) based on District recommendation and review of the Contractor problems, resolutions and QCP.
Acceptance does not relieve the Contractor of responsibility for supplying and installing a finished product conforming to all requirements of the Contract.
403.03 Quality Control Program (QCP). Create and implement a Quality Control Program (QCP) for each paving season. The Quality Control Plan will cover processes conducted to provide an asphalt mixture at the paving site that is uniform in composition, conforms to the specification requirements and that when placed is free of any defect (ex. segregation, lack of mixture and texture uniformity, raveling, rutting, holes, debris etc.) within the Contractor’s control at project completion. A minimum of 3 weeks before mix production, but no later than February 28, submit the proposed QCP to the Laboratory for review and approval.
Send a copy of the approval letter and approved QCP to the DET in every District in which work is performed. Keep copies of the approval letter and the approved QCP in each Contractor plant laboratory and plant operation control room.
Failure to comply with the approved QCP may result in removal of personnel in accordance with Supplement 1041, removal from VA, and adversely affect the Contractor’s Prequalification rating.
The QCP is a reflection of a Contractor’s sincerity and ability in producing a quality product. Development of this program beyond the minimum requirements specified below is encouraged and is taken into consideration by the QCQC when reviewing Contractor plant operation for qualification for VA.
Include in the program:
A. The assignment of quality control responsibilities. Quality control includes all efforts required to achieve a product meeting specifications. The QCP will list individuals as required below and note their designated responsibilities to meet QCP requirements. Provide a Quality Control Manager holding a Supplement 1041 Level 3 approval and who is a company employee. Assign Level 2 technicians for all Level 2 QC testing duties only. If Level 2 consultant technicians are used provide a document in the QCP and to them listing designated responsibilities and expected actions (if different from employee expectations). Provide a Field Quality Control Supervisor, holding Supplement 1041 Field Quality Control Supervisor approval and who is a company employee, who is routinely and usually at the paving site during placement of any non-temporary asphalt concrete pavement.
B. Provisions to meet the Department mix specifications.
C. Procedures for any extra testing (e.g., job start, responses to poor test results or field mix problems, aggregate stock testing, reclaimed asphalt concrete pavement checks, moistures) and any other testing necessary to control materials not already defined in these Specifications.
D. Copies of worksheets, test reports, and forms used in the quality control.
E. Procedures for record storage, test equipment maintenance, and documentation.
F. Method of Quick Calibration and documentation for each plant type.
G. Procedure for random sampling to be used and documentation method.
H. Procedure for ensuring that every Contractor employee involved in the testing of asphalt mix and operation of the asphalt plant facility has read the QCP and has on site access to all applicable Department specifications, proposals, policies, and the current approved JMF.
I. Means to meet the handling and storage requirements of 402.08 and asphalt binder suppliers for all asphalt binders.
J. Means to meet delivered mixture uniformity/coating and hauling/trucking requirements.
K. Signature of the Quality Assurance Manager and, if different, the person in authority to enforce all operations covered by the QCP as outlined in this subsection.
L. Define the roles and responsibilities of the Field Quality Control Supervisors. List approved Field Quality Control Supervisors.
403.04 Plant Calibration. Conform to the requirements of Item 402.
Before manufacturing asphalt concrete, demonstrate to the Monitoring Team that the Contractor’s facility adequately meets the specification requirements. Calibrate the plant using procedures approved by the Department. Perform initial calibrations in the presence of the Monitoring Team. The Monitoring Team may request a letter of certification and certified data documenting the calibration results, instead of having the Monitoring Team present.
Verify the calibrations biweekly using a Quick Calibration. However, the Department may request additional Quick Calibrations if there are mix production problems or plant operation concerns. The Quick Calibration is a quality control procedure developed by the Contractor that verifies the accuracy of a facility to proportion materials to meet the current JMF. Include the Quick Calibration procedure and data forms in the QCP. If the difference between current calibration and the Quick Calibration is within ±2 percent, then the current calibration is acceptable. If the 2 percent variation is exceeded, perform a recalibration of the facility. Document the Quick Calibration procedure as specified in the QCP and post the procedure and results in plain view in the plant control room and plant laboratory for reference by the Monitoring Team. Document all data from calibrations in a format approved by the Laboratory, and retain the data for review by the Monitoring Team.
If asphalt concrete is being produced from a batch type facility, verify the accuracy of the aggregate and asphalt binder weighing devices on a biweekly basis. Include the verification procedure in the QCP. Document the verification procedure as specified in the QCP and post the procedure and results in plain view in the plant control room and plant laboratory for reference by the Monitoring Team. Do not allow the deviation between the plant recorded weights and actual weights to exceed 1 percent. Record all data from verification of weighing devices in a format approved by the Laboratory, and retain the data for review by the Monitoring Team.
403.05 Quality Control Tests. Perform quality control tests to control the asphalt concrete mix within the appropriate specifications.
Perform all Item 448 mix testing and quality control according to 441.09. The Contractor may test a 448 Sublot sample instead of the required quality control test provided the sample is tested in the half day in which the Sublot sample mix was produced and is tested for all required quality control properties.
For mixes that do not use Item 448 acceptance (e.g. Items 301, 302, and Supplemental Specification 803), test the mix according to 441.09 for asphalt binder content and gradation (Basic). Other requirements of 441.09 and 441.10 do not apply. Control the Basic mixes as follows:
A. If a single asphalt binder content is more than ±0.5 percent beyond the JMF, immediately take and test an additional sample.
B. If two consecutive asphalt binder content tests are more than ± 0.5 percent beyond the JMF, notify the Monitoring Team and cease production until the problem is corrected.
C. If the Range difference in any three consecutive asphalt binder content tests is greater than 0.7 percent (for 302 mix) or 0.6 percent (Basic mix, other than 302) immediately notify the Monitoring Team.
D. If the Range difference in any three consecutive gradation tests for the No. 4 (4.75 mm) sieve is greater than 10.0 percent, immediately notify the Monitoring Team.
E. If Range deviations as specified continue, cease production.
Range is defined as the difference between the largest and the smallest test result.
403.06 Verification Acceptance (VA). The Department will perform VA. If the random Department sampling and testing verifies the accompanying Contractor tests, the results of all the Contractor’s quality control tests for each day (for Basic mix) or the Contractor’s tests for each Lot (for 448 mix) will determine acceptance.
A. Sampling. The Department will perform the VA by testing independent and split samples taken and tested by the Department.
For plant sampling for Basic mixes or 441 quality control testing, the Contractor’s technician will randomly select the truck in which to take a sample by using a random number procedure as outlined in the QCP. The Contractor’s technician will give no indication to anyone of the time that the sample is to be taken. For other than job start, previous mix production problems, low production tonnage, or as requested by the Monitoring Team, exclude the first three trucks from sampling. Include the random number and sample tonnage location and time of taking on the daily Quality Control Report (Department Form TE-199) with each test. Tests, other than the required random sample tests, are at the Contractor’s discretion according to the QCP.
Provide a clean area of sufficient size to perform
sample splitting. Split samples by
quartering according to AASHTO
T 248, Method B and recombining for the Department and Contractor’s sample. The Department split sample size required is
generally 22 to 27 pounds (10,000 to 12,000 g).
Ensure that every quality control or Item 448 Sublot sample taken by the
technician has a labeled split for the Department. Wrap and label the Department split samples
as to
For Item 448 mixes, conform to
the procedures of Supplements
1035, 1038,
1039,
and 1043
except take samples from a truck at the plant.
If workmanship problems continue on the project (segregation, etc.) or
if quality control problems persist, the Monitoring Team may require sampling
on the road according to Supplement
1035. Lots will be 3000 tons (3000
metric tons), and Sublots will be 750 tons (750 metric tons). However, when production is limited to less
than 3000 tons (3000 metric tons), consider the quantity produced as a partial
B. Reporting. Report all testing performed and sample identification on a Quality Control Report (Department Form TE-199). Deliver (fax, e-mail, hand) completed Quality Control Reports by the end of each day in which testing is conducted. If desired by the Monitoring Team and always for unsigned E-mail versions, mail the originals. After startup adjustments, report any plant operation changes on the Quality Control Report. Ensure that each Quality Control Report contains technician comments as to production quality, input materials received, and condition and includes any other quality control activities as specified in the QCP. Ongoing problems with inadequate, incomplete, or illegible reporting will result in a change to Unconditional Acceptance. The Contractor’s technician must sign each Quality Control Report.
Report test results to the accuracy of the following decimal places. When the figures to be dropped in rounding off are exactly one-half of unity in the decimal place to be retained, round the value up or down to the nearest even number in the decimal place to be retained..
|
|
Single Test |
Mean |
|
Asphalt Binder Content |
0.1 |
0.01 |
|
No. 200 (75 mm) sieve |
0.1 |
0.01 |
|
Other sieves |
Whole number |
0.1 |
|
BSG |
0.001 |
0.001 |
For Item 448 mixes, track the Item 448
Sublot and
C. Department Verification Testing and Monitoring. The Monitor will randomly choose one Department sample in a maximum of every four production days for VA testing to confirm Contractor testing and mix control. More frequent VA samples can be taken when desired. The Department VA sample location will be chosen randomly by the Monitor, including where in the truck to take the sample. The Contractor technician will take the sample from the truck with the monitor witnessing. The Monitor will keep the sample in the Department’s possession until delivered to the District lab or testing is complete. The Monitor will have enough sample taken to split with the Contractor. The Monitor will split the sample in the contractor lab. The Monitor will have the sample tested in the District lab or as noted below. The Contractor will test his split of the VA sample with the Monitor witnessing. The Department will use it’s VA test result; the Contractor result of the split: as well as the most recent previous contractor quality control and/or sublot test in the comparison for the Department VA testing.
The Monitor may opt to test the Department VA sample in the plant laboratory with the Contractor’s permission, according to the Contractor’s safety practices, and with the restriction of only the Contractor’s technician physically placing a sample pan in the AC Gauge. However, if the Department tests VA samples on contractor equipment 1 in every 5 VA samples must be tested in the District lab on its own equipment. Record the results and testing location in the District project record. One day may be added to the above Department sample testing frequency for each day production is less than 500 tons (450 metric tons).
For all mixes, the District may increase the VA testing frequency if desired.
All Department VA test results will be given to the Contractor by a reasonable arrangement acceptable to both. Department VA sample testing not completed in a timely manner is of no value in verifying quality control testing quality for Contractor test acceptance and/or investigating problem causes. As such, if not completed in a timely manner, Contractor tests will automatically stand and the District will note the problem in the District’s VA record.
|
Table 403.06-1 DEPARTMENT VERIFICATION ACCEPTANCE AND QUALITY CONTROL TEST COMPARISON |
|||
|
|
Percent Asphalt Binder |
Percent Passing No. 4 (4.75mm) |
|
|
|
VA[1] QC/lot test[2] |
VA[1] |
QC/lot test[2] |
|
Basic |
±0.3 ±0.4 |
±4.0 |
±5.0 |
|
448 |
±0.3 ±0.3 |
±4.0 |
±4.0 |
|
[1] |
|||
|
[2] |
|||
If the Department VA tests confirm Contractor testing is within the verification tolerances, but a pattern of high or low results exist that suggests mix control is not at the JMF, then investigate with the Monitoring Team’s assistance to correct the problem to the Monitoring Team’s satisfaction. Direct any questions regarding interpretation of circumstances to the Laboratory.
D. Contractor Tests are Verified. Production is acceptable if:
1. the Monitoring Team verifies the Contractor’s QCP is being fully followed; and
2. the Department VA tests are within the limits specified in 403.06.C; and
3. for Basic mixes, the remaining sieves do not exceed the limits of the applicable specification.
Failure on the Contractor’s part to respond and resolve Monitoring Team concerns may result in a change to Unconditional Acceptance.
Acceptance is based on Table 403.06-2.
|
Table 403.06-2 Mix Acceptance |
|||
|
Mix Type |
Acceptance Tolerances or Method |
||
|
Basic Mixes |
|
Deviation from JMF |
Range |
|
|
Asphalt Binder Content |
± 0.5% |
1.0 |
|
|
No. 4 (4.75 mm) sieve |
± 6% |
12 |
|
Basic Mixes |
Use acceptance limits in appropriate specification |
||
|
448 Mixes |
Calculate pay factor according to 403.08 |
||
E. Contractor Tests not Verified. If the Department VA test does not verify the accompanying Contractor tests within the verification tolerances, then the Monitoring Team will investigate.
If the deviation between the District and Contractor test is greater than the limits in Table 403.06-3 immediately cease production until resolved. If the deviation is less than the limits in Table 403.06-3 and discrepancies continue, perform additional tests to aid in problem solving.
|
Table 403.06-3 Deviation Limits |
||
|
Property |
Mix |
Limits |
|
Asphalt Binder Content |
All |
± 0.5 % |
|
No. 4 (4.75 mm) sieve |
All, except 302 |
± 6.0% |
|
302 |
± 7.0% |
|
Additional tests may include any testing necessary
to resolve the problem. If the additional
testing does not resolve the problem by one-half production day or 1000 tons
(1000 metric tons), whichever occurs first, to the Monitoring Team’s
satisfaction, stop production, if not already, until problems are resolved.
Contact the Laboratory for assistance in resolving problems. If the District testing program is confirmed
by the additional tests and Monitoring Team investigation and no reason to
question the original test exists, then the original
After the above investigation, one of the three following actions will occur:
1. Mix Production Compares Well to the JMF. If the District test and investigation shows mix is actually controlled well compared to the JMF in spite of the Contractor test, the District does not have to test additional samples if the Contractor testing problem is corrected.
2. Mix Production Does Not Compare Well to the JMF. If the District tests and investigation shows lack of Contractor mix control compared to the JMF the District will test the remaining Department split samples for the days or Lots represented by the original tests. The District will use the test results to calculate the acceptance. While working with the District, immediately take steps to correct the problem according to the QCP. Failure to achieve a quick resolution will result in a change to Unconditional Acceptance.
3. District Testing Problem. If the District testing program has a problem as confirmed by the additional testing and District review, the District will correct the problem, throw out the original District test results and take new samples from the samples representing the days or Lots in question for the VA tests.
F. Contractor Removal, Restoration. If repeated problems with poor comparison of tests are not the District’s fault; or poor comparison of Contractor tests to the JMF; or with plant operation, input materials, or any of the other requirements of Department specifications occur in a single project or successive projects, the District will request an opinion from the QCQC before notifying the Contractor of removal from Department VA. The District will immediately notify the Contractor of the removal with a follow up letter from the District Engineer of Tests. Once notified, acceptance of asphalt mixtures is by Unconditional Acceptance. Restoration of the VA procedures may occur on a future project with a District recommendation to the QCQC based on consistent improved plant operation and mix control, a review of the Contractor problems and resolutions, and a review of the QCP by the QCQC.
403.07 Unconditional Acceptance. If the Contractor is removed from Department VA, the following will occur.
The Contractor must bring its QCP and operation to a level acceptable to the District and QCQC before production continues. The DET will ensure that the project C-95 (Contractor’s Prequalification Rating survey) will reflect the change to Unconditional Acceptance in all of the appropriate C-95 categories. The Department will accept all material for Department projects from the facility under Unconditional Acceptance. While the facility is under Unconditional Acceptance, acceptance of small quantities under the small quantities policy will not apply.
Quality control testing requirements specified in 403.05 are modified as follows:
A. The required number of test series is a minimum of three each per production day or night. If a production day is less than 6 hours, the Department may reduce the frequency but not less than one test series per every 3 production hours.
B. For Basic mixes, if the variation from the JMF for one test is ±8 percent passing the No. 4 (4.75 mm) sieve or ±0.3 percent asphalt binder content, investigate and correct the problem, then resample and test. Maintain the moving average of three tests within ±4 percent passing the No. 4 (4.75 mm) sieve and ±0.2 percent asphalt binder content. In addition to the Quality Control Report, maintain control charts according to 441.10 for asphalt binder content and the No. 4 (4.75 mm) sieve. If the Range difference in any three consecutive tests is greater than 0.6 percent for asphalt binder content or 10.0 percent passing the No. 4 (4.75 mm) sieve, notify the Monitoring Team. If Range deviations as specified continue, cease production.
C. Report each day’s testing on a Quality Control Report, according to 446.04. Report all testing performed by the Contractor’s technician on the Quality Control Report. After startup adjustments, report any plant operation changes on the Quality Control Report. Ensure that each Quality Control Report contains technician comments as to production quality, input materials received, and condition and includes any other quality control activities required in the QCP. The Contractor’s technician must sign each Quality Control Report. Attach each day’s computerized plant printouts to that day’s report. The technician must note on the accompanying printout in which tonnage the quality control sample was taken with accompanying test results for asphalt binder content and percent passing the No. 4 (4.75 mm) sieve. Keep a copy of all Quality Control Reports for a project in the Contractor’s plant laboratory.
The District will monitor according to 441.06, except notification for ceasing production does not have to be in writing. Additional samples may be obtained for Department test at any time.
For Basic mixes, if the mean of the
|
Table 403.07-1 Basic Mix Pay Factors |
||||
|
Number of Tests |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
|
Pay Factor |
0.98 |
0.97 |
0.96 |
0.95 |
For Item 448 mixes, the Department will perform
acceptance sampling and testing according to 403.06 and
403.08, except the
403.08 Acceptance Tables for 448 Mixes. A Lot is considered acceptable for gradation and asphalt binder content if the deviation of the mean from the JMF and the Range is no more than the tolerances shown in Table 403.08-1.
Table 403.08-1 Deviation from the JMF and Range Tolerances[1]
|
Mix Property |
Deviation from JMF (Percent) |
Range (Percent) |
|
Asphalt Binder Content |
0.4 |
1.0 |
|
1/2 inch (12.5 mm) sieve |
6 |
15 |
|
No. 4 (4.75 mm) sieve |
5 |
15 |
|
No. 8 (2.36 mm) sieve |
4 |
15 |
|
[1] Based on mean of four Lot Acceptance tests. |
||
If the mean of the Lot acceptance tests for a particular sieve or sieves, or for asphalt binder content deviates from the JMF by more than the tolerances shown in Table 403.08-1, but falls within the tolerances shown in Table 403.08-2, then the Lot is considered reasonably acceptable and may remain in place with payment at a reduced pay factor as show in Table 403.08-2.
If the Range of the
Table 403.08-2 448 Acceptance Schedule[1]
|
Mix Property |
Pay Factor |
1 Test |
2 Tests |
3 Tests |
4 Tests |
|
Asphalt Binder Content |
1.00 |
0 to 0.80 |
0 to 0.57 |
0 to 0.46 |
0 to 0.40 |
|
0.98 |
0.81 to 0.90 |
0.58 to 0.64 |
0.47 to 0.52 |
0.41 to 0.45 |
|
|
0.94 |
0.91 to 1.00 |
0.65 to 0.71 |
0.53 to 0.58 |
0.46 to 0.50 |
|
|
0.85 |
1.01 to 1.10 |
0.72 to 0.78 |
0.59 to 0.64 |
0.51 to 0.55 |
|
|
0.70 |
1.11 to 1.20 |
0.79 to 0.85 |
0.65 to 0.69 |
0.56 to 0.60 |
|
|
[2] |
> 1.20 |
> 0.85 |
> 0.69 |
> 0.60 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1/2 inch (12.5 mm) sieve |
1.00 |
0 to 12 |
0 to 8.5 |
0 to 6.9 |
0 to 6.0 |
|
0.99 |
13 to 14 |
8.6 to 9.9 |
7.0 to 8.1 |
6.1 to 7.0 |
|
|
0.97 |
15 to 16 |
10.0 to 11.3 |
8.2 to 9.2 |
7.1 to 8.0 |
|
|
0.94 |
17 to 18 |
11.4 to 12.7 |
9.3 to 10.4 |
8.1 to 9.0 |
|
|
0.90 |
19 to 20 |
12.8 to 14.1 |
10.5 to 11.5 |
9.1 to 10.0 |
|
|
[3] |
> 20 |
> 14.1 |
> 11.5 |
> 10.0 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
No. 4 (4.75 mm) sieve |
1.00 |
0 to 10 |
0 to 7.1 |
0 to 5.8 |
0 to 5.0 |
|
0.99 |
11 to 12 |
7.2 to 8.5 |
5.9 to 6.9 |
5.1 to 6.0 |
|
|
0.97 |
13 to 14 |
8.6 to 9.9 |
7.0 to 8.1 |
6.1 to 7.0 |
|
|
0.94 |
15 to 16 |
10.0 to 11.3 |
8.2 to 9.2 |
7.1 to 8.0 |
|
|
0.90 |
17 to 18 |
11.4 to 12.7 |
9.3 to 10.4 |
8.1 to 9.0 |
|
|
[3] |
> 18 |
> 12.7 |
> 10.4 |
> 9.0 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
No. 8 (2.36 mm) sieve |
1.00 |
0 to 8 |
0 to 5.7 |
0 to 4.6 |
0 to 4.0 |
|
0.99 |
9 to 10 |
5.8 to 7.1 |
4.7 to 5.8 |
4.1 to 5.0 |
|
|
0.97 |
11 to 12 |
7.2 to 8.5 |
5.9 to 6.9 |
5.1 to 6.0 |
|
|
0.94 |
13 to 14 |
8.6 to 9.9 |
7.0 to 8.1 |
6.1 to 7.0 |
|
|
0.90 |
15 to 16 |
10.0 to 11.3 |
8.2 to 9.2 |
7.1 to 8.0 |
|
|
[3] |
> 16 |
> 11.3 |
> 9.2 |
> 8.0 |
|
|
[1] Based on mean of Lot Acceptance tests from the JMF. [2] Remove and replace material. [3] Engineer will determine if the material may remain in place. Pay factor for material allowed to remain in place is 0.70. |
|||||
The Department will determine payment for the
The Department will base acceptance of partial Lots on the mean and the Range of the results of tests on the number of samples obtained.